Dems Wrestle With Health Care Message 07/20 06:26
WASHINGTON (AP) -- Cheered on by a handful of activists, liberal House
Democrats announced outside the Capitol that they were forming a caucus to push
for "Medicare for All" --- shorthand for government-financed health care.
At the same time Thursday, Democratic senators were introducing a resolution
aimed at putting Republicans on the defensive about Trump administration
efforts to undermine former President Barack Obama's health care law.
Neither proposal has much chance of going anywhere in the Republican-run
House or Senate. But the bigger problem for Democrats is that the two messages
--- fundamentally reshaping the nation's health care system versus defending
Obama's popular law --- divide the party as it tries grabbing control of
Congress in this fall's elections.
All Democrats oppose President Donald Trump's repeated efforts to scuttle
Obama's Affordable Care Act, and many have backed expanding government-paid
health care, including Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif. But many also
think drawing campaign-season attention to Democratic efforts to reinvent the
country's $3 trillion-a-year health care system, a costly and complex
undertaking, is a mistake.
Promoting "Medicare for All" opens the door for Republicans to accuse
Democrats of plotting tax increases, unaffordable federal costs and the loss of
employer-provided coverage, these Democrats argue. They say it's better to play
offense by focusing on controlling medical costs and opposing GOP efforts to
demolish the 2010 health care law.
"Every Democrat is being asked, 'Do you support this or do you not?' and
it's becoming a political wedge in an election year," Rep. Kathleen Rice,
D-N.Y., said of the "Medicare for All" drive. "And I think we should be
focusing on the terrible things that are happening under this administration
The new caucus has more than 60 members, nearly 1-in-3 House Democrats,
including many from safely blue districts where liberal voters prevail. Backing
"Medicare for All" lets them tap into activists' fervor for universal health
care that helped propel Vermont independent Sen. Bernie Sanders to an
unexpectedly strong challenge to Hillary Clinton for the 2016 Democratic
"If you live in America, you've got a right to affordable quality health
care, period," said Rep. Debbie Dingell, D-Mich., a caucus founder, prompting
applause from supporters watching her group's news conference Thursday.
Rep. Pramila Jayapal, D-Wash., another leader, later said she backs a 2017
House bill providing free health care financed partly by boosting taxes on
wealthy Americans. That bill has more than 120 Democratic co-sponsors. But she
said her group's goal is to build consensus for legislation it may introduce
next year, with decisions remaining about costs, financing and other questions.
A similar bill by Sanders last year drew 16 Democratic co-sponsors,
including at least four potential 2020 presidential contenders. Sponsors
haven't released price tags, but Sanders said a version he promoted during his
2016 campaign would have cost $1.4 trillion annually --- a figure some analysts
said was far too low.
"The only proposal here is a 'Medicare for All' caucus to figure out what
the right proposal is," Jayapal said.
That's not stopping the GOP from getting ready to jump on the issue. By
combing through candidate and newspaper websites, social media and other
sources, Republicans have compiled quotes from around two dozen Democratic
House challengers embracing "Medicare for All." A Republican provided the
information on condition of anonymity to disclose internal preparations.
"It would break Medicare," said House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy,
R-Calif. "And it would end any private insurance as we know it."
Trump and congressional Republicans tried repealing the ACA last year and
failed. But they've taken incremental whacks at it, including cutting federal
subsidies to many insurers, erasing the penalty for people who don't buy
insurance and opening the door to low-cost plans providing less coverage.
That's exactly where many Democrats running in swing districts are
concentrating their messages.
Democrat Clarke Tucker, challenging Arkansas GOP Rep. French Hill, said in
an early TV ad, "I'll stand up to anyone who tries to take your health care."
And Rep. Ami Bera, D-Calif., said in an interview, "I'd say we ought to focus
on Republican efforts to undermine the ACA right now and the impact that's had
on costs going up."
That was also the focus for Democratic senators in their resolution Thursday
authorizing the Senate's legal counsel to intervene in a lawsuit in which 20
GOP-led states allege the health care law is no longer constitutional.
The Trump administration said last month it will stop defending key parts of
the law in court, including provisions protecting patients with pre-existing
medical conditions. Polls show large majorities favor helping those consumers.
Democrats want the Senate counsel to defend the protections for people with
pre-existing problems. There's little chance Republicans controlling the Senate
will allow such a vote, which Democrats hope would put GOP senators in an
"This is a test of the Republican Party, whether or not they are going to do
the right thing," said Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa.